Why performance marketing means nothing without consumer trust

Performance marketing success has become diluted and lost its grounding in business outcomes. At the same time, consumers have become harder to reach as they take non-linear paths to purchase. Attention spans are shrinking, and trust — the driving force behind long-term brand affinity — is wearing thin.

Today’s ad landscape is also flooded with product launches, algorithmically-boosted videos and cookie-cutter content. Likewise, the growing use of AI has made it increasingly difficult for consumers to discern what — and whom — to trust.

As a result, customers are demanding more transparency, responsible data collection and privacy practices, and authentic communication. Prioritizing these practices is essential to building lasting trust — because once broken, it can undo even the strongest performance results.

Behind the scenes, internal marketing teams often work in silos, with conflicting metrics to judge success. Walled gardens limit transparency, and everyone claims attribution — making it difficult to know what results actually mean. Therefore, measurement often becomes a box-checking exercise instead of a true signal of business impact.

In this type of environment, metrics can be easily manipulated, but trust cannot. And brands can’t earn trust by playing it safe. That’s why trust is the new performance indicator.

Trust is the metric that actually moves product

Building brand trust requires more than frequently exposing shoppers to a brand’s messaging. Consumer trust is earned through meaningful connections. A brand must know its audience, what the brand stands for and why that brand matters in a consumer’s world.

Trust deepens when a brand’s voice, targeting and presence come together consistently to create experiences that are rooted in storytelling, feel relevant and resonate emotionally — not that simply prompt transactions.

​​Few media channels deliver consumer trust as powerfully as out-of-home. It’s a high-impact ad format that meets customers where they physically are, without disrupting their daily routines, to naturally build brand connections. It adds brand relevance to a given moment in time, such as a highway sign advertising a fast food restaurant at an exit ahead, an ad for chilled Gatorade on a sweltering day or a Calvin Klein billboard that can’t be ignored.

More than just reach, OOH offers impact and the chance to be unforgettable. It sparks emotion or provides a nudge that primes someone to act. For example, electrolyte drink mix company Liquid I.V. recently tapped into workers’ 4 p.m. workday slump with a Times Square billboard takeover that reminded them to recharge and refresh.

When done right, OOH is not just an ad, but a real-world moment that breaks through the clutter and sparks downstream engagement like searching for a product, visiting a store or clicking on a mobile ad with newfound familiarity. This is why research shows that 80% of consumers have researched a company or product after seeing an OOH ad.

Unlike other ad formats, OOH is public, physical and intentional. It carries brand-building weight that physically smaller digital ad placements can’t replicate. It also plays a powerful supporting role across other media channels, such as when a consumer hears an ad while streaming a podcast, or when a social media user sees a sponsored Instagram post after passing a storefront installation.

OOH is an ad channel that adds meaning to other brand touchpoints for consumers.

Building brand loyalty with emotion and intention

Inundating audiences with too many emails or banner ads isn’t a useful strategy for building consumer trust. In fact, it often drives consumers away. Instead, brands should focus on developing emotional storytelling and buying thoughtful ad placements.

The key is to move audiences emotionally, be that through clever messaging or visually striking imagery. Over time, this builds brand loyalty and performance success. Heritage brands, for example, have used this type of strategy for years. A premium watch or luxury handbag ad isn’t simply about the items being advertised — it’s about legacy, memory and emotion.

OOH advertising builds on emotional storytelling by adding a layer of flexibility. For example, a high-impact takeover doesn’t have to last weeks to be effective or appear on the biggest screens. Some of the most powerful advertising moments can be woven into the fabric of a city or community by creating short, sharp bursts of energy that capitalize on buzz, then exiting before the audience tunes out.

OOH is performance with trust that’s measured in impact, not just in impressions.

Brands are trading vanity metrics for real impact

The most important brand metrics are often the ones that are hardest to measure. Insights like emotional connection, cultural relevance and brand love don’t immediately show up on dashboards, if at all.

But that doesn’t mean they don’t matter. In fact, they’re foundational. Trust builds memory, which builds preference — ultimately driving action.

There are quantitative ways to track brand trust, such as measuring sales lift, website traffic, brand searches, engagement on social media, returning customers and dwell time. However, qualitative indications of brand trust are just as important, including whether the campaign creative started a conversation and was shared or talked about on social media.

There is no question that making sales is essential to a brand’s success. However, if an entire media strategy hinges solely on proving that every dollar spent leads directly to a purchase, brands miss the bigger picture. Long-term performance success comes from brand-building, and that starts with trust.

Performance marketing success is fleeting if consumer trust hasn’t been built. In a world in which audiences are inundated with advertising, building consumer trust also builds brand loyalty. It’s not a metric; it’s the mandate. And no brand can buy customer loyalty. Trust must be earned, or performance means nothing.

Sponsored by Vistar Media